UK Parliamentary Investigation into The Integration of Smallholder Farmers into Supply Chains: Call for Evidence

Have your say in the UK Parliament’s latest investigation

INTEGRATION OF SMALLHOLDER FARMERS INTO SUPPLY CHAINS

Co-ordinator, All Party Parliamentary Group on Agriculture and Food for Development

The All Party Parliamentary Group on Agriculture and Food for Development (APPG) has recently launched a new UK Parliamentary Inquiry examining existing how smallholder producers can sustainably and equitably be integrated into supply chains. The APPG would welcome the views of Business Fights Poverty members on this subject including thoughts on the roles and responsibilities of three key sectors – namely the Private Sector, Governments and Donors and Civil Society – including examples of best practice where they exist.

The Secretary of State for International Development has announced that 2013, with the UK in the G8 Presidency, will see his Department make a significant announcement on its work on Food and Hunger and we hope that our study, and therefore your comments, will directly contribute to his Department’s thinking in this area.

You can post your comments below, or submit your written evidence directly to me by email by Midday 24th February. Additional details can be found in the Call for Evidence which can be forwarded on request.

Agricultural investment continues to fill up the column inches both in the UK and in Africa. It is no longer a contentious point that African agriculture has been underfunded by both African Governments and Donors alike. Yet in recent years far more rhetoric has been placed on record for the need for sustainable investment in African agriculture and nowhere is the need more pressing than among smallholder farmers.

In 2003 African Governments stepped up and committed 10% of their budgets to agriculture, yet barely one-fifth of Governments has achieved this aim. Similarly Donors like the UK have begun to recognise the need for a renewed focus on agriculture as a key driver for economic development and poverty alleviation.

Considering that agriculture is the lifeblood of African economies and societies – with more than half a billion Africans or some 65% of the population dependent upon small or micro-scale farming as their primary source of livelihood this is not so surprising. Indeed a 2010 GALLUP poll of Sub-Saharan citizens placed agriculture as the number one issue that was spontaneously raised as a priority area for Government intervention.

At the same time there appears to be growing interest in the potential for African farmers to access markets and increase their income through involvement in the supply chains of domestic and international markets with a demand for their goods.

A number of large multinational companies, for example, have developed supply chains involving smallholder farmers which have, in some instances, been well documented. There is also an apparent growth in interest in investing in African agriculture from venture capitalists and other investors and these projects provide an avenue for that investment. Similarly, the development of local SMEs is beginning to be recognized as of equal importance as national and local private sector actors begin to integrate the outputs of smallholder farmers into their supply chains.

It is clear that the commercial potential of African agriculture is only now being recognized. Indeed the McKinsey Global Institute estimate this potential as enough to raise average annual agricultural output from $280bn dollars today to $500bn in 2020 and to $880bn in 2030, whilst at the same time creating an additional $275bn in upstream and downstream markets.

Despite this the outcomes of private sector investments to date are far less widely documented than those of civil society and national governments, thereby presenting a huge opportunity for learning and scaling up best practice in these areas. As such the study will seek to examine issues of smallholder integration at every scale and discuss what constitutes best practice from the standpoint of each stakeholder.

The purpose of this investigation is to broaden the discussion to other case studies and to look in more detail at the roles, responsibilities and interests of each of the key actors as well as smallholder farmers themselves.

The study will run from January until May this year and culminate in a short pragmatic final paper identifying the optimal circumstances for the successful integration of smallholder producers into supply chains; describing current best practice in all stakeholder groups and; outlining the key steps required to introduce and, ultimately, scale up such success stories.

The study is seeking to obtain evidence in response to several specific questions, whilst also exploring some of the broader issues, including:

  • What do successful endeavours in this area look like and how, and at what level, are success and impact best measured over time?
  • What are the needs and responsibilities of each partner in supply chain projects?
  • What have we learnt about how to structure and organise projects so that they are sustainable and have maximum benefit to all partners?
  • What are the drivers behind partnerships focused on building inclusive business models in agricultural supply chains in Africa?
  • What role does i) governance of and ii) investment in the agricultural sector play in encouraging or hindering the development of supply chains involving smallholder farmers?
  • What specific policy solutions could be implemented to expand the number of such projects and what can be done to promote the inclusion of marginalized groups, women farmers and youth?
  • How do such projects measure their impact and the benefit to each of the partners?
  • How can successes in this area be scaled up and where do such examples exist?

We feel that this study is especially timely given the focus the UK Secretary of State for International Development has placed on private sector development as a crucial means for ensuring countries ultimate graduation from aid. Given that agricultural growth is 2-4 times as effective at reducing poverty as growth in any other sector and that 450 million smallholders worldwide currently feed over 2 billion people – that the potential of integrating smallholders into supply chains in a sustainable and equitable way can play a significant role in reducing hunger and poverty and the creation of vibrant rural economies across Africa and the developing world.

We look forward to hearing your views.

Share this story

3 Responses

  1. I put this question to a Ugandan forum on Facebook and this is what I got back

    from Ebrah K I don’t know if we have a completely free market economy but for starters the powers that be should give’ fair trade’ agricultural produce buyers the chance to purchase as much produce as they can before licencing other produce buyers that exploit farmer. Farmers need not look at government for this, an informed person should mobilise cooperatives in their village to facilitate collective bargaining. DFID could perhaps help with financing information dissemination amongst these cooperatives….information about things like organic fertilizer partly made out of urine, or pesticides made partly of common soap that such farmers can easily make but have no clue it even exists. A pal at Kawanda Research station informed me on a recent trip that agricultural extension services had broken down but all this information is available. DFID could help in organisation, funding purchase of a few Bajaj motor cycles and enabling exchanges in farming technology.In a way this would save Britain and Britons money because ours is a low cost of production country for agriculture…therefore having food security means less need for the government to contribute to food aid programs. Having food surplus in such countries means lower food inflation for a Briton at the supermarket and a much needed income for small farmer (read forex for the government to improve it’s balance of trade, with all its attendant advantages). These improvements coupled are likely to contribute significantly to political stability, preservation of which is a little known function of DFID.

  2. I am currently working with coffee farmers in Rwanda, helping to develop the leadership skills of the women within the cooperatives, as this has been shown to help the cooperatives become more sustainably competitive.

    I am working in partnership with an INGO who I have seen being repeatedly successful at building farmers groups, training them in quality practices, linking them to the market and then leaving them to work on their own. It is a joy to see the evidence of this happening, and I think that the answer to ‘What do successful endeavours in this area look like…’ is a long one. However, I have seen 1) a strong focus on sticking with a few farmer groups that are the focus from the beginning to end 2) prioritizing transparency and good accounting practices before moving on to other things and 3) excellent partnership between the INGO and the local government and businesses. 

  3. I recommend looking into the example of the sugar sector in Tanzania.  The key success factors there seem to be (1) strong farmer associations at multiple levels (local, regional, national) which represent farmer interests, organize provision of services e.g. harvesting and transport, and bring best practices, (2) private sector millers willing to give contracts, (3) and of course liberalization of the industry which was previously state run.  The associations have also developed an interesting farm block model which in addition to raising incomes in the short to medium term, could be part of the answer to the longer-term question “what comes after smallholder farming” in that it generates income and frees up time for other economic endeavors.  The Tanzanian Sugar Growers’ Association would be a good source.  Your folks in Dar may have a connection; if not send me a note and I can introduce.

Leave a Reply

Featured

Spotlight

Next Event

Latest